hero image

GlobineView

Monitor and manage renewable energy with real-time insights

Client
Globine Energy - Ireland
Industry
Renewable Energy, Agrotech
ROLE
Lead Product Designer
team
3 designers
Project
4-week contract
tOOLS
Figma, Illustrator
Project Scope
GlobineView mobile app is the proposed end user application to help the Irish dairy farmer monitor the production of renewable energy biogas using Globine Energy's AD system (anaerobic digestion) - a system that transforms cow manure into biogas and organic fertilizer.
Deliverables
  • Secondary research
  • Heuristics evaluation
  • Competitor analysis
  • Information architecture
  • User stories
  • Task flows
  • Design system
  • High fidelity mockups
  • Prototype
  • Usability Test
OVERVIEW

Globine Energy, an Irish startup specializing in renewable energy and agrotech, sought to develop a digital solution that would enable users to effortlessly track and manage energy production from their new conceptual product, the on-farm 45KW AD system. During our initial meeting, we identified significant challenges, including the absence of a business plan, product specifications, and funding, as well as differing expectations from stakeholders (farmer vs scientist).

BUSINESS GOALS
  • Identity core features
  • Develop conceptual prototype
  • Test within resource constraints
  • Lay foundation for future development
UX METRICS
  • Usability
  • User Satisfaction
  • Feature Comprehension

Curious about our project's impact and the final product? Discover if we achieved our goals in the 'Did we meet our goals?' section.

Click here.

Problem

The average Irish dairy farmer has some basic understanding of anaerobic digestion system. They see the value of adding the AD system to their farm but are concerned about the initial upfront cost and how hard it would be to learn how to use the system.

Solution

I led a team of 3 UI/UX designers to create an intuitive and easy to use mobile application for the AD system. Our main goal was to make the Irish farmer feel comfortable using the solution to see and manage energy production, equipment performance and real-time alerts.

How might we?
outcome

We successfully developed a functional prototype of the GlobineView mobile app. We received positive feedback from initial usability testing, indicating a high user satisfaction rate. The initial  user engagement metrics showed promising adoption rates and interaction with key features. Globine Energy has now a working prototype to apply for funds and take GlobineView to the next level.

prototype

Play with the prototype delivered to our client.

VIEW PROTOTYPE
PROJECT SETUP

Laying the foundation

Before starting the project, I needed to understand Globine Energy's goals, the AD system, and their target market. This helped me create a solid project plan and assign tasks to my team effectively.

To set my team up for success, I collaborated with them to identify their strengths and foster leadership skills. I divided the project into three phases, assigning each designer to a phase based on their preferences. I led the Define phase.

Using Agile Scrum, I broke the project into four one-week sprints. After our initial meeting, we clarified the project plan and scope, ensuring we met the client's expectations and stayed on track.

Kell
Amita
Anthony
Stakeholder 1
Stakeholder 2
Stakeholder 3
Sending a questionnaire to clients prior to our Kick-off meeting helped us focus on the main tasks at hand: Understanding the business, the market and the user.
research

What is the product and who is the user?

Due to the technical and unfamiliar nature of this project, we began with secondary research on Anaerobic Digestion (AD) machines and a thorough analysis of current competition. We identified our primary user as a typical Irish dairy farmer and invested our initial efforts into understanding on-farm AD systems, Irish dairy farming practices, and their intersection. We developed a focused research roadmap aimed at gathering valuable insights into our users.

Through our research, we grasped the complexity of the on-farm AD system and the differing expectations of our stakeholders—a scientist and a farmer. The system includes multiple user interfaces: the AD system dashboard, the biogas meter dashboard, the admin team dashboard, and the end-user application.

scope of work

Setting proper expectations

For the first time, our stakeholders understood our task was to design the end-user application. However, the scientist wanted to provide technical data to the average dairy farmer, which proved more challenging than anticipated.

Thankfully, our research findings presentation helped us finalize the project plan and scope, ensuring everyone had aligned expectations for the product design.

What are the competitors doing?

AGMRI
Biogas
GSI
Smart Biogas
Bushel Farms

Heuristics evaluation

We conducted a heuristic evaluation utilizing 5 of Nielsen's 10 usability heuristics on competitors' apps. This step was crucial to identify common usability issues. A great alternative to usability testing when working on a limited UX research budget.

heuristic evaluation of agrotech, renewable energy mobile applications

Heuristics evaluation insights

When evaluating the top apps in the market—AGMRI, Biogas, AGCO GSI, Bushel Farm, and Smart Biogas—we were unpleasantly surprised by the poor performance in key heuristic criteria such as visibility of system status, match between system and the real world, user control and freedom, error prevention, and recognition rather than recall. Here were the top 3 issues found in our heuristics evaluation:

heuristics evaluation 1
Error prevention and visibility of system status

No feedback about the sign in process or a clear option to sign up for the app.

heuristics evaluation 2
Match between system and the real world

The icons on the bottom navbar, such as the "cow" icon, did not make sense to the users.

heuristics evaluation 3
User control and freedom

Although users can easily exit unwanted states, creating a new account leads to a broken link, preventing users from returning to the main screen.

Competitor Analysis

We identified direct and indirect competitors in the AD industry and reviewed their websites and mobile applications. We compared key features, functionalities, and design elements that overlap with our mobile app. Through SWOT analysis, we evaluated each competitor's strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats. We analyzed their interface design, navigation, content presentation, and overall usability, identifying best practices and innovative solutions to inform our client's MVP development.

Key Findings

Key insights and discoveries

In the course of our deep dive into this project’s technical landscape, I was amazed by what we found. While there are solutions for renewable energy, through heuristic evaluation and competitor analysis, we found out that they are limited and often lack user-centric design. Through user interviews and secondary research, including insights from the Irish Farmers Association, we gained a comprehensive understanding of our target audience—the Irish dairy farmer. This research allowed us to tailor our approach to meet their specific needs and design a solution that truly resonates with end-users.

Overwhelmed users

While the Irish dairy farmer recognizes the benefits of new technology like the on-farm AD system, they feel overwhelmed by new technology and worry about the initial upfront cost of the system.

Too technical

There are available options for AD systems that collect cow manure and transform it into biogas and organic fertilizer. However, they are highly technical and difficult to read and navigate.

Unique opportunity

By investing in user research and user-centric design, Globine Energy sets itself a unique opportunity to become a trendsetter in the renewable energy sector by providing the Irish dairy farmer and easy to use solution.

Heading 1

Heading 1

Heading

Heading

Heading

Heading
Heading
opportunity
What seemed overwhelming at first, turned out to be a great opportunity to relate with and advocate for the end user.

Identifying core features

Initially, our clients resisted the research phase. However, that changed when I explained the various components of an AD system. I hosted a one-hour workshop with stakeholders to collaboratively identify the core features needed for the initial phase.

TEAM BUILDING

Design challenge

Leading this team for the first time, I initiated a quick 10-minute design challenge to break the ice and learn about each other's work styles. Each designer tackled one main route, and this exercise proved to be a fun and productive way to get to know each other.

Design challenge exercise Kell hosted with her fellow UX/UI designers.
initial mockups

Design deliverable

We now had our initial mockups. We were excited to have kept the user as the center spot throughout this process, keeping the screens similar to other mobile applications, avoiding technical jargon, and simplifying how to display the technical data.

the curve ball

A new challenge

During the mockup presentation, the stakeholders shared screenshots of a different farming app they wanted to emulate. Despite being informed about upcoming accessibility legislation changes in Europe, they insisted on specific graph types for performance tracking. We provided accessibility audit reports with recommendations, but the client declined to implement them.

We were adamant about addressing specific usability issues while being flexible to other changes. Being able to quickly adapt and collaborate with stakeholders and my fellow designers allows us to deliver an iteration before our in-house usability test.

Main screens iterations

Home screen iterationsPerformance screen iterationsAlerts screen iterations
DESIGNING THE BRAND

Creating the logo

Creating a brand platform and visual style for this innovative solution aimed at Irish dairy farmers was crucial. To spark creativity, I organized a design challenge focused on the logo. Each designer submitted a logo, and I was thrilled when the stakeholders selected my design.

Agrotech app logo design by Kell Egbert
TESTING THE SOLUTION

In-house usability testing

Due to time constraints and limited resources, prototype testing was done during the final meeting. Even though the prototype was only tested with a small group of participants, 100% of the users were able to easily navigate and complete the three main tasks. The insights were crucial for improving the monitoring application.

Main insights

user input after usability testing
usability testing user feedback
usability testing user feedback

Iteration based on usability testing

Given our limited resources, we focused on testing the overall feel of the app. Specifically, we wanted to see if users knew how to add biogas data and how to access time-sensitive alerts and respond to them appropriately.

Task #1 - Add biogas data

All users easily understood the elements on the homepage. However, 25% of users had concerns:

  • They preferred a button rather than a link to tap when adding biogas data.
  • The headers for each card were small and lacked contrast.

These minor style changes made the screen much easier for users.

Home screen iteration after usability testing done.
Home screen iteration after usability testing done.

Task #2 - Read and address time-sensitive alerts

Participants tested how easy it was to read alerts on their mobile app. The color-coded alerts, varying by severity, were well-received. All users accessed alerts from the home screen to the alerts page and decided to either "Chat" or "Call" for help or "Close" the alert by tapping "Done." Surprisingly, the only request was to add a way back to the home screen by tapping the app logo, even though a "Home" icon is in the bottom navbar.

FINAL SCREENS

High-fidelity screens in record time

After quick testing during our final meeting, I led an internal meeting with my design team to finalize design changes and create documentation for recommendations during the project handoff. In the retrospective meeting, I reiterated the main concerns we needed to address for our end user and how we resolved them. Here are the top solutions for the minimum viable product:

high fidelity screens - Home

All-in-one screen

The home screen shows dairy farmers how the system is performing. They can also add their daily biogas production directly from the home screen. We simplified complex information for an intuitive approach, using large icons, high color contrast, and avoiding technical jargon.

Driving efficiency and performance

GlobineView empowers farmers with real-time performance data, driving efficiency and optimizing performance in dairy farming operations. Users can access performance metrics for each of the 14 subsystems, view historical performance data, and add media and notes to the platform.

high fidelity screens - Performance
high fidelity screens - performance

Making production status easy

With just one tap from the home screen, dairy farmers can get an overview of their production status. Key metrics such as electricity production and biogas generation are presented in an intuitive interface. The user-friendly design empowers farmers to optimize their system's efficiency and productivity without technical expertise.

Actionable insights from real-time alerts

We addressed the lack of clarity in competitors' alerts by implementing a color-coded alert system directly accessible from the home screen. Clear instructions guide users on how to contact the admin team or address issues themselves, ensuring our app meets the diverse needs of farmers.

high fidelity screens - Alerts
high fidelity screens - help and contact

Going above and beyond

By optimizing our team's schedule through Agile scrum methodology and swiftly adapting to client requests, I empowered my team to deliver additional screens, including Help & Account, going beyond the initial scope. My goal was to provide the client with a well-defined design template for all future screens, expediting development, testing, and launch. This proactive approach not only met but exceeded the client's expectations, showcasing my commitment to excellence.

RESULTS

Did we meet our goals?

Our objective for Globine Energy was to simplify biogas production management for the average Irish dairy farmer and provide Globine Energy with a fully functional prototype to seek funds and launch a competitive renewable energy production app. We achieved great results for both the client and users:

100% achievement

Transitioned Globine Energy from zero-to-one, taking the GlobineView mobile app a step closer to development, testing, marketing, and launch.

€40 million opportunity

Final deliverable provided tangible evidence of the app's user-friendly nature and technical robustness, potentially unlocking €40 million in investment.

100% user success

Achieved a flawless user testing record, with all testers successfully navigating through all app features and functionalities, highlighting the app's intuitiveness and accessibility.

achieving our goals

Looking back at our initial objectives, it's clear that our concerted efforts and strategic planning led to significant achievements. We not only met but exceeded our business goals and UX metrics, ensuring the successful development of a functional and user-friendly prototype. Here’s a detailed overview of how we accomplished each goal:

BUSINESS GOALS
  • We Identified core features in collaboration with stakeholders in our 1-hour workshop
  • We created a high-fidelity prototype that incorporated user feedback and aligned with the business goals, ready for initial testing.
  • We conducted in-house usability testing with limited resources, ensuring that the prototype was functional and intuitive for users.
  • We provided a comprehensive design template and documentation, setting a clear path for future development and potential investment.
UX METRICS
  • Achieved a 100% success rate in usability testing, with all participants easily navigating and completing tasks.
  • Positive feedback from all users during testing, indicating high satisfaction with the app's design and functionality.
  • Users demonstrated a clear understanding of the app's features, with minor adjustments made to enhance clarity and usability.
NEXT STEPS

Building on our success

We've provided final handoff documentation with actionable items crucial for the product design's success, considering new laws, user-centric designs, and best practices.

Kell created a document with final recommendations for the success of the renewable energy mobile app

Recommendations

We provided a final document advising our stakeholders to prioritize user insights. They should be focusing heavily on further usability testing. We reemphasized the need to reduce technical jargon and focus on accessibility. Thinking on accessibility and that this app would most likely be used outdoors, we suggested the design of a dark mode option.

Dark mode

Considering the typical usage scenario of dairy farmers outdoors during daylight hours, we proposed implementing a dark mode theme for the application. This feature enhances readability and reduces eye strain, especially in bright environments, ensuring a better user experience.

home screen dark mode
account screen dark mode
help screen dark mode
Lessons Learned

What I've learned

As I concluded this chapter of our project journey, I carry forward invaluable lessons and insights gained from our experiences.

The power of collaborative work

This project reinforced the importance of collaborative work. By strategically allocating tasks to each team member, fostering a culture of mutual support, and keep constant contact with stakeholders, we achieved remarkable results.

Adaptability leads to client satisfaction

By championing a flexible approach that embraced last-minute shifts, I propelled us toward our project’s successful completion. Client was happy with the final deliverable and we felt accomplished.

Dedication to learning and innovation

Entering uncharted territory with the AD systems project, I embraced the opportunity to explore new technologies and industries. The renewable energy sector was a complex area to work but also very rewarding.

Testimonials

Throughout my journey, I've had the privilege of working with and learning from a diverse group of professionals. Here’s what some of them have to say about our collaboration and the impact of my work.

Agrotech renewable energy mobile app design
Kell is a born leader, but still very conscientious of the input and ideas from those she is working beside. Her ability to steer the client conversations into productive and tangible outcomes and actions items guided our definition of a realistic and quality MVP for the client.
Testimonial 1
Anthony Cain
UX/UI Designer, worked under Kell's team leadership at Globine Energy
Agrotech renewable energy mobile app design
As our team leader, Kell excelled during both the overall project and specifically in the Define Phase. Kell's got this magic touch with clients. She can steer conversations and get them on board with ideas that actually work. This helped us design a super usable MVP that the client loved.
Testimonial 2
Amita Shah
UX/UI Designer, worked under Kell's team leadership at Globine Energy
Agrotech renewable energy mobile app design
Many thanks again to Kell. We appreciate all the hard work over the recent weeks. You are so organized. The further recommendations were very helpful.
Stakeholder
Collaborated with Kell at Globine Energy as a stakeholder
top arrow